1st Avenue Redesign

Project Overview

This project will redesign 1st Avenue from Downing St. to University Blvd., widening the Cherry Creek Trail, adding a tree lawn to the south side of 1st Ave., making safety improvements at the Downing St. and University Blvd. intersections, and preparing the corridor for future Bus Rapid Transit (BRT).

This project was identified as a high priority by Denver Moves: Cherry Creek (DMCC). The Cherry Creek trail between Downing and University is too narrow to meet Denver's standards for a regional trail. Through community outreach for DMCC, the project team heard that many residents are concerned about safety and comfort on the trail, as well as the intersections that bookend the project.

The goals of this project are to:

  • Improve safety and comfort for people walking and rolling on the Cherry Creek Trail.
  • Achieve a true "parkway" feel by adding trees on the south side of 1st Ave.
  • Improve safety and comfort, especially for vulnerable road users, at intersections.
  • Preserve space to operate future BRT.
  • Increase mobility options for people who live in or travel to/through Cherry Creek.

Project Area

This corridor is a critical connection between Downtown Denver, the heart of Cherry Creek, and points west and east of these destinations. The project area includes the intersections at Downing/Speer/1st Ave. and University/1st Ave.

Map of 1st Avenue between Downing St and University Blvd

 


Frequently Asked Questions

How was this project identified to advance?

In 2024, DOTI completed work on Denver Moves: Cherry Creek (DMCC) - a cohesive strategy for the development of future transportation infrastructure in and around Cherry Creek.

This project combines three of the highest priority projects developed through the DMCC process:

  • 1st Ave & University Blvd intersection improvements
  • 1st Ave & Corona/Downing St intersection improvements
  • widening the Cherry Creek trail (including mobility, safety, and transit improvements)

Through the DMCC process, community members expressed a high amount of support for these projects and verified the critical need.

What work has been completed to date for this project?

Through the DMCC process, the project team evaluated several alternatives to understand the feasibility of each option. Alternatives were presented to the public at meetings and outreach events. The team worked with partners at Denver's departments of Forestry, Parks and Recreation, and Community Planning and Development to ensure buy-in from these key stakeholders.

A preferred alternative was selected and the team developed a concept, which was memorialized in DMCC(PDF, 20MB) (page 48).

How far will the current design process advance the project?

This project will advance the design to what we call "30% Design" - a preliminary design phase. At this stage, the design is roughly 30% complete and is used to establish the project's overall scope and technical direction. When this (current) project is complete, we will have a better understanding of potential conflicts, cost, and steps for finalizing design.

When will the project be constructed?

Advancing a project of this scale to the 30% design phase is a critical step in moving the project toward construction. This work will help determine an estimated project cost, which positions DOTI to identify, apply for, and secure funding sources for construction. A timeline for construction is not yet known, though it could take several years from plan recommendation to implementation for a project of this scale.

How much will this project cost to build?

DOTI considers this type of project a Large Capital Project, meaning it will cost more than $1 Million to construct and will include major roadway reconstruction. We are refining the cost estimate as design advances.

How wide is the existing Cherry Creek Trail in this section, and what width should it be per Denver's standard for regional trails?

This section of the trail (which does not include the sidewalk on the bridge) varies from 8-9 feet. The Denver Parks & Recreation standard for a regional trail is 12 feet - which this project is aiming to achieve.

Why was narrowing the median preferred?

After thoroughly vetting several options, the project team and partners agreed that the alternative with a narrowed median achieves all project goals with fewer tradeoffs than other options. This solution achieves the following:

Safety

  • Improves safety by using trees and a curb to create an 8 ft buffer between vehicle traffic and vulnerable road users, making conflicts less likely. This option will also widen the trail to the 12-foot standard, providing safe space for bi-directional travel and the passing of bicyclists and pedestrians using the trail.
  • Currently, plowed snow is pushed to the road edge and can encroach on the sidewalk, creating a safety issue and further narrowing usable trail width. This option will create space for snow storage during winter months.

Comfort

  • New shade, vertical separation, and a wider trail vastly improve comfort for trail users. Drivers on 1st Avenue also have a more comfortable experience due to shade and separation from the trail.

Historic Preservation

  • Adding a tree lawn to the south side of 1st Avenue would bring it closer to the vision established by Denver's parkway standards, including the Speer Blvd/Cherry Creek Parkway Urban Design Guidelines.

Mobility

  • Retaining all lanes of travel allows current vehicular traffic (including transit) to keep moving and ensures there will be space in the roadway to operate future Bus Rapid Transit.

What alternatives were considered for widening the Cherry Creek Trail?

The project team investigated:

  • Removing an eastbound traffic lane along 1st Ave
  • Temporary solutions
    • Shift curb slightly north (~1.5 ft)
    • Install jersey barriers
  • Shifting entire trail to north side of 1st Ave
  • Implementing center running bike lanes
  • Expanding trail to the south and shift into Denver Country Club property
  • Shifting entire trail to follow Cherry Creek through Denver Country Club property

Option

Why Not Preferred Alternative

Remove eastbound traffic lane

1st Avenue is one of the busiest streets in Denver. At peak hour, 1st Avenue experiences congestion, which impacts general purpose traffic and existing transit. This is a future Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) corridor, which requires either a shared or dedicated transit lane. Removing a travel lane in either direction would make future BRT difficult or impossible to implement.

BRT represents a critical solution to manage congestion along the corridor as the area continues to grow, as forecasted through the DMCC process (see DMCC(PDF, 20MB), page 28).

Widen trail by moving curb slightly north

Shifting the curbline represents a major construction project, even if the width of the change is small. Moving the curb at all would require removal and replacement of the existing curb and would likely require reconstruction of the sidewalk and drainage infrastructure, which makes this a costly alternative. The existing travel lanes are already narrow, providing only 1.5 feet to widen the trail. The project team determined the benefits gained by this modest widening would not be worth the high project costs, especially as a new 9.5-10 ft trail would not meet Denver's 12-foot standard for regional trails. Any funds spent on a short-term solution would detract from funds for a future project.

Install "jersey barriers" or other temporary vertical separation

In the current condition on 1st Ave, there are two feet between the striped southernmost travel lane and the gutter pan. DOTI standard requires two feet between a travel lane and a vertical barrier, which means the barrier would need to be placed on the trail at sidewalk level. A typical jersey barrier is two feet wide at its base. Using this treatment would narrow the traversable width of the trail to 6 feet, which is already sub-standard and does not provide adequate width to accommodate the current volume of people walking and bicycling, nor facilitate safe passing.

Other options for vertical separation exist, but again, would be relatively expensive and result in a narrowed usable trail width, exacerbating existing safety issues. Continued investment in a sub-standard solution detracts from resources that can be invested in a better outcome.

Shift trail to north side of 1st Ave

Shifting the trail to the north side of 1st Ave would entail major street reconstruction impacts and costs. This configuration would create 8-10 additional conflict points for people walking and rolling at Downing St, University Avenue, and all of the intersections between those streets on the north side of 1st Ave.

If the trail shift were to begin at Lafayette Pl (where the trail currently comes up to the bridge) either a new traffic signal or major changes to the Downing St bridge over Cherry Creek would be required to facilitate two-way trail travel. This could trigger a bridge removal/replacement - a highly expensive capital project for a bridge that is currently in good condition.)

Additionally, people using all modes of travel generally take the most direct path. Diverting the project away from the existing trail would likely lead to a decrease in users of the new/improved trail. In summary, this expensive option would introduce new safety issues and be inconvenient to use.

Implement center running bike lanes

Similar to the option above, implementing center running bike lanes would create new conflict points (and safety risks) as cyclists would have to cross eastbound travel lanes to enter and exit the new trail. Where turn lanes exist at Gilpin St and University Blvd, the trail is too narrow to accommodate a bi-directional trail. This option would also require removal of most (if not all) existing trees in the median.

Shift into Denver Country Club (DCC) property (either directly south or following the Cherry Creek Trail)

These options would be unnecessarily costly from a land acquisition perspective compared to the preferred solution, which meets all project goals and enhances the historic condition of the parkway.

Both options present significant technical challenges that would come at additional cost, including: building infrastructure to eliminate conflicts between golf play and trail use, replacing infrastructure on the golf course that would be impacted/altered due to introduction of a new trail, analyzing and mitigating impacts to the creek from an ecological perspective, and mitigating impacts to existing structures and facilities close to the DCC existing property line.

1st Avenue in this location is a historic parkway. How was this considered when choosing an alternative?

DOTI worked with Community Planning & Development's Landmark Preservation Team through the DMCC process and confirmed their approval before choosing a preferred alternative. The project team continues to work with Landmark Preservation and community partners to ensure the project is in alignment with the street's historic designation. Documents that guide changes to this parkway include:

  • Denver Parkway Design Guidelines
  • Speer Blvd/Cherry Creek Urban Design Guidelines

While the north side of the parkway has an established tree lawn, most of the southern section between Downing and University Blvd lacks this important historic characteristic. Denver's Parkway Guidelines call for canopy trees on the outside of vehicle lanes to create a park-like atmosphere and feeling of enclosure. The Speer Blvd/Cherry Creek Parkway Design Guidelines also call for definition: landscape features used to clearly delineate the active and passive; pedestrian and auto; and formal and informal areas within and adjacent to the boulevard. From this view, the proposed project would enhance the historic vision for the parkway.

How will this project change the median from how it looks today?

To make room for a wider trail and new tree lawn on the south side of 1st Ave, the median will need to be narrowed. The precise extent of median reduction will be determined through this project. The project will add a new tree lawn on the south side of the street and look for opportunities to plant new trees in the median. The project team consists of tree experts who have assessed the entire median and the team is working together to minimize impacts to existing trees through design.